5 Ways to Lead on Performance Appraisals

performance appraisals, 5 Ways to Lead on Performance Appraisals

Performance Appraisals start with Good Leadership

If you’re leading a team, department, group or sub-group, all those Performance Appraisals add up – and they add up to an appraisal of you – as a leader.

At the end of the day, every individual performance appraisal reflects not just on the employee being skewered, but on the leadership that employee is subjected to.

In most cases, “subjected to” is exactly the right phrase. If you’re overseeing any number of workers  – be it five or 50 – then carefully directing each and every one of them to a stellar performance appraisal is critical. To your success, to the success of the entire business.

But far too often we hear that when it comes down to that all important performance evaluation – alas – everyone is on their own.

Don’t leave it up to your people to make it on their own. It’s not only bad leadership but it’s a recipe for bad performance, listlessness and time wasting, and frankly, a whole host of other ills that will plague your team right out of business.

On the contrary, try these 5 simple steps that will get your people not only involved, but succeeding – along with you. Maybe even in front of you… right where you want them.

5 Vital Ways to Engage All Your People Before their Performance Appraisals Come Up

1) Get Critical

Seriously. Formally. Put a constructive criticism mechanism in place and stick with it. Make sure you can take as much feedback as employees can give back and listen to it. Then, be sure that all of the feedback can be reviewed by everyone involve and acted upon.

2) Check Resources

Do you have everything you need? Remarkable how seldom that question gets asked. Is there something we can give you that will help you to get your job done better? Providing what’s needed gives hope to the hopeless, inspires the listless and lifts spirits everywhere and all around. Watch the motivation happen once the basics are provided for.

3) Learn About Values

There’s a huge debate that’s ongoing – in all corners of business – about Values. Don’t assign them. Listen to them. Learn from them. Celebrate what you really have in common. Better yet – find out what you have in common. Most companies – and even team-mates – don’t know. Have team members work on and develop and understand three things that they really believe in. Do this company-wide, or department-wide, and then compare. Then develop a working list that everyone agrees on and see what happens when you take it public.

4) Go Back to Freelancing!

As we wrote here just a few weeks ago:

Your employees can’t learn everything they need from inside your company. If they lack curiosity, they also, likely lack engagement!

Disengaged employees get bad appraisals and they cost you money. Star players are probably working two or three other gigs – freelance or project-based gigs where they are learning how to do what they do, better. Encourage them, and learn from them. Have them give presentations so that they get practice selling their services – and so that you’re other people are encouraged to develop and sell their skills too. Every department is a mini-service provider with your company as client number one, but you need service providers with a lot of clients. It’s not just about the big, dumb, arrogant company. VALUES!!!

Learning from everyone might be a good value to start with!

5) Innovate

Innovation doesn’t happen with paranoid conservative leadership. Sorry. Innovation happens with some risk, and a lot of freedom. Read back through all of the above, and review where you can let some of these things happen. Like…

  • What do you need? More regular time off? Are you ready to give it?
  • One thing you could learn here is ______. Are you ready to learn?
  • What we all really agree upon is A. B. C. and the biggest surprise of all, D. Be ready to accept it and understand it.
  • You’re working on what? How can that possibly relate to us? Again, be ready to be surprised. Most leaders simply are NOT ready!
  • Lastly, we’re taking a risk, giving you what you want so that you can innovate. We’re doing that because we believe you going where you want to go benefits all of us. Now, where are we going?

All of this is a guarantee not only for better employee appraisals, but for management appraisal reports too. What would you do differently? Let us know in the comments below.


Photo this page: Howard Gospel Choir 3 © Creative Commons License by US Embassy Sweden

Karin Jakovljevic

About the author

Karin Jakovljevic

Karin Jakovljevic is the head of marketing at Ximble, a powerful, cloud-based workforce management system, simplifying employee scheduling and time tracking for retailers, restaurants and small businesses.

Success Stories


It was hard to keep Menchie’s young and mostly part-time staff informed about shift changes, until Menchie’s discovered Ximble’s easy-to-use smartphone app.

Fast Fix

Ximble’s easy-to-use scheduling tool allows Fast Fix employees to remotely access shift information, and integrates with their Point of Sale and Payroll systems.

Spry Health

When spreadsheets became too complicated, Spry Health sought simple, cost-effective timekeeping software so they could concentrate on growing their business.

Spirited Gifts

Since switching to Ximble, Spirited Gift no longer struggle with employees turning up at the wrong time, for the wrong shifts.

Re-bath of South Florida

Re-bath required timekeeping software that was simple, flexible, and that could grow with their business.


When they outgrew their own internal system, Vastrm chose Ximble to track their part-time and contracted employees, both in and out of the office.

Excellence Martial Arts

All that Excellence Martial Arts were looking for was basic employee timetracking, with payroll reporting. Ximble’s cost-effective software was the ideal solution.

Collab Inc

Manual timesheets were a poor fit for Collab, and with no easy to feed the data into Gusto they began looking for a viable solution to their scheduling and time tracking headaches.

Carolina Moves

Follow Carolina Moves’ journey as they transitioned from using an archaic time tracking and data entry methods to using something that could optimize their processes and integrate with Gusto.

Bearings Bike Shop

Read how inaccurate time keeping methods forced Bearing Bike Shop to approximate working hours leading to significant losses over the year, until implementing Ximble.

Mermaid Life Chameleon

Needing a simplistic solution to their scheduling and time tracking needs, Mermaid Life didn’t want a solution that would over deliver and overcharge for what they required.

Krein Knives

Outgrowing spreadsheets, Krein Knives now needed a time tracking solution that could accurately track irregular working hours and automate as much of the administrative process as possible.


Looking for automation and simplicity, Garmentory turned towards Ximble in hopes of resolving their time tracking woes.


With their eyes set on rapid growth, Novvia needed to implement a scheduling solution that could effectively scale as the business grew while integrating with the existing payroll system.


Discover how Story2 resolved their time tracking and payroll problems by implementing Ximble into their arsenal of tools and integrating it with their payroll platform, Gusto.

CareCentric Pty Ltd

Spreadsheets lacked the scalability and flexibility that CareCentric Pty Ltd needed as they grew and needed something that would be responsive to their changing needs.

Bou Cou Dancewear

Struggling with varying availability of staff, scheduling for multiple store fronts and managing payroll, Bou Cou Danceware needed a solution to their scheduling and time tracking needs.

Best Pets Veterinary Hospital

Constantly fighting wasted time from data entry errors, outdated methods of scheduling and time tracking were taking their toll. Discover how Ximble helps them overcome their challenges.

Hook SEO

Read how Ximble helped Hook SEO with their time tracking and scheduling problem when they noticed too much time was being wasted on data entry.

National Strategic

After a rapid increase of employees, National Strategic’s dependence on spreadsheets for time tracking was no longer viable. Find out how Ximble solved their problems.

miR Diagnostics

Find out how miR Diagnostics implemented Ximble’s time tracking features for their employees and how it improved their payroll operations through the Gusto integration.

Followell Fotography

Effective time tracking in and out of the office and Gusto integration was important for this photography company. Find out how Ximble stepped up to meet the challenge.


Ximble provided an inexpensive and user friendly solution to CARP’s time tracking and Gusto integration needs. Find what won them over and how it bettered their operations.


Discover how the time tracking and extensive feature of Ximble helped improve ILKB’s operations with the Gusto integrations and ximbleChat platform without breaking the bank.


A tech savvy company that integrates technology into your offices and homes. With their skill and knowledge, they turn your ideas into reality.

Wise Owl Animal Hospital

An animal hospital that combines traditional and modern medicine to provide superior animal care. They raise awareness and provide advice on excellent pet care.

Armstrong Property Management

A property management consulting that specializes in home real-estate. They offer an abundance of services to property owners.


A restaurant consulting company that helps you take your business to the next level. With the best advisors, they can help you expand your business.

Liquid Consulting

A consulting company that strives to become your food processing partner. Comprised of skilled technicians and employees to improve your business.

Alta Animal Hospital

Find out how Alta Animal Hospital do away with printed shift calendars and move to a 100% mobile platform.


Read how Ximble helps Montefiore eliminate the need for multiple spreadsheets and calendars.

Rudy’s Pub & Grill

By utilizing Ximble, Rudy’s Pub & Grill has seen a 60% decrease in missed shift from schedule confusion.


Learn how TouchSupport was able to manage employees at multiple locations with ease and save 8 hours a week by using Ximble.

Try Ximble for 14 days free

No credit card required. Cancel any time.